At 6'2" the Guts tall soft is very comfortable. The stock tall seat is very hard, but, it serves it's purpose by not collapsing much when you sit on it.
I rode with the stock HBG tall seat for a long time, as I had given my stock seat to Guts for them to make the mold off of. They sent me the tall soft after they had finished with making that seat, and I left it in the box for a while before trying it. After I did, I thought myself and ***** for not putting it on sooner!
The Guts tall soft is so much more comfortable, that it is worth not having that little bit of extra height that the stock tall seat gives. And both are way better than the stock seat in terms of comfort for the longer legged of us.