you did good not changing too much
say with the Bv you could try
16,24,24,24,24,24,24,22,22,20,18,16,14,12,10,18
not too much different to what youve got
then try
24,24,16,24,24,24,24,22,22,20,18,16,14,12,10,18
then
24,24,24,16,24,24,24,22,22,20,18,16,14,12,10,18
24,24,24,24,16,24,24,22,22,20,18,16,14,12,10,18
then move it 2 spots
24,24,24,24,24,24,16,22,22,20,18,16,14,12,10,18
then take it out, then pull one of the 22s and the bottom 18. put the 16 instead of the heavy 18 to protect the stem.
24,24,24,24,24,24,22,20,18,16,14,12,10,16
thats what I did. but I needed a stiffer long stroke HS so I put 24s under the 10 but thats probably not needed on an FS unless you charge gutters head on.
I'll try and explain a bit of what I found out about boingers in case its interesting
It looks like the heavy MV spring on your bike. its not all that bad really to have a heavy MV spring (mine is a monster) if you do something like this to soften the initial harshness say just with what you have
MV
24,18, 24,24,20,11, 24, 22
the 18 is like a bleed shim but you can't put it on the MV directly without screwing up the rebound consistency so one step away is next best. if it dives too much you can close up the float with more shims under the stack or use the 20 or 22 as the bleed instead of the 18. if its too harsh cut the 18 down to a 16 or a 14 or a 12.
ultimately it would probably be considered by most to be better to do something like lew
but I do like the heavy spring with a bleed stage.
(lews stack)
Mid-valve
24x.15
20x.1
14x.1
(2)10x.20
16x.1
20x.1
light ck-spring (same as popups or a KYB)
there are a lot of ways to think about which shims do what and where and many tuners have different ideas and argue themselves silly about it all on furums, everyone can get good suspension from applying their own approach if they do it methodically and logically. the carb comparison is pretty good though I don't think that any fork valve knows which part of the stroke its in? only how far the rod has moved from rest and how fast the rod moves.
that is i think that you can have some stroke sensitivity (short or long stroke) from the shimstacks with stages particulary the BV but not really technically posititon sensitivity unless every hit is taken from full extension then its the same thing to a degree. just MHO
the strength and prelaoding of the MV spring control some very Low speeds and contribute to initial harshness.
the MV float influences how high in the stroke the forks will ride and how responsive they feel, but as the float reduces percieved stiffness increases so as you reduce the float you may want to reduce the number of shims in the MV stack, reducing the number of shims in the stack reduces their support and lifespan. I'd not go too much below 1.2 mm in those forks without building some kind of extra support for the shims.
which shims do which speed ... ah I think all the shims influence everything a bit.
in the BV stack the face 24s in particular (like the Mv spring) influence every speed because obviously they have to move first before any oil passes them though they are mostly thought of as LS and short stroke HS.
its more complicated than this but say
24,24,24,24,24,24,22,20,18,16,14,12,10,16
your supposed to pull out the 12 to make it softer for rocks if there is any on the road? say potholes . or pull the 12 and the 14 and replace them with a 13.
if you change the 10 to a 9 or an 8.5 you make the whole stack softer but you also alter the balance between HS and LS (stifness varies as the beam length cubed)
to have a stiffer LS/MS you add 24s (LS) but that also stiffens everything or a 19 or 17 or 15 (MS) but that also stiffens HS so then you have to comphenstae by changing the pivot or pulling the 12.
harder than which shim does what is deciding which speed needs to be stiffer or softer for a given application and ony trial and error can really help there.
lots of guys pull out too many 24s on the BV or have a piddly little first stage to try and reduce initial harshness which is better dealt with on the MV. what they often get is a wallowing bike with an odd harshness and a very lumpy progression through the stroke that blows through when pushed.
the challenge is to get a stiff enough LS and MS to stop wallowing and blowing through the stroke without any initial harshness or a too stiff HS.
its very possible and very rewarding though it does take some time to find stuff out. there are a few other little tricks to help like a very thin face bleed shim on the BV, Ill explain that if anyone is interested in using one.
FWIW i think about 20% of possible improvements lie in the rebound stack of most bikes.
sorry for the long post, got a torrets thing or summink .. once i start.... gotta finish
I hope its helpful somehow or at least a bit of a laugh
regards
Bushie