AKA, "05 550 Berg vs 06 KTM 450 EXC" or, "why is nsman trying to kill me?"
Anyway,here goes
Temp-60'F Elevation 200-700' asl.Ride-too much fireroad with some snotty singletrack and mud and rocks and roots.Less of the latter than intended due to the fact that I was unable to fid my way due to excessive clearcutting and new logging roads.
All in all the bike was amazing.I had heard that these could be intimidating but it didn't seem so at all.All kinds of power if you wanted it but enough torque to pull a taller gear at lower speeds if you didn't.
Jetting-close,but not quite.I can't speak for the stock jetting as this bike had the Lineaweaver jet kit installed from new.Bill,the mechanic at Valley Yamaha wasn't happy with the stock set up so that was good enough for me.I had a hard time kick starting it at these temps with my mx boots(e start worked readily enough)Also had a slight lean hesitation off the bottom and slight popping on closed throttle.However,I can kickstart it easily in the basement with my slippers on(wife takes exception to this for some reason)where the temp is about 70 degrees.For now I plan to richen up the fuel screw slightly as the weather is cool and I expect as soon as it warms up to the usual summer riding temps the jetting will be spot on.I may end up going one size larger on the pilot for spring and fall but I'll wait and see.Having the accelerator pump hooked up would have no doubt been an aid for cold starting but given how it starts at a slightly warmer temp I expect this won't be an issue with some minor adjustments.Not that I doubt Mr. Lineaweavers credentials or abilities,but having been an auto mechanic for 20+years and being well familiar with the old days of carburetors and accelerator pumps and the purpose of the pump as well as the resulting problems when they went bad(and also coming off a two stroke)I had my doubts that you could disable the pump and still be able to whack it open at low rpm to clear a rock or log without having it bog.As it turned out,it has no bog whatsoever.Even the slight lean hesitation is no issue as it blows past this point and puts you straight up in a hurry-and this is from second gear at a rockcrawling pace.I guess I should have known.Sorry Dale
Suspension-pretty good but seems to have a tendency to wash the front end out.The first time it did this I made a heroic attempt to dab with my head but this proved less than effective.After that I was prepared for it and managed to compensate.This may be my own doing as I have the rear sag set at 105mm so may have to jack this up a bit.I took a few hard hits at speed as well as a few slap down wheelies and small woods type jumps and still had about 2.5" of unused front travel(I have o rings on the lower tubes)so I may have some adjustment range here as well.
Handling-seems good but slower than what I'm used too(02 KTM 125SX)
When weighting the pegs for a left,right,left transition to go around rocks or whatever it takes a little more time to initiate.Given the engine size and weight this wasn't unexpected.I think a little fine tuning is in order but all in all it seems to work very well and tracks straight over the crappiest of terrain.
Engine- :shock: :shock: :shock: Yahooooo..all kinds everywhere.What more can you say.I now have 118km/2.7 hrs on it so I changed the oil and filter.Oil looks slightly dark with some sludge on the magnet.The screen has a dozen small chips on it and the inside of the filter has just a couple small chips in it.Nothing at all like the scary looking long slivers I used to get off previous KTM's.
Misc.-I love the adjustable brake pedal.For some reason,my toes always hang down past the front of the pegs when sitting or standing and I've never been able to position it in such a way that I don't have to ride with my foot pointed out or dragging the rear brake-until now.It seems like a small thing but it makes a big difference to me.
As for a comparison of the two,I couldn't get over how soft and cushy his seat was.My previous KTM's(an EXC and an SX)were hard as a board.The Berg seat is better than those but his seat is better than that.Soft and cushy but you don't feel the base.It reminds me of a Honda seat.Not a big issue but definately noticeable.
The other thing I noticed when getting on the EXC was how low it sat.The suspension hardly sagged with my weight(I'm 160,he's 210)I could flat foot it with a slight bend in my knees.This was good for getting your foot down to save it at times but it was also a much more scrunched up riding position.I have bar risers on the Berg but even allowing for this the EXC position seemed much more compact.The KTM is also more plush in the slow going rocky stuff but it is also more prone to goat dancing,head shaking,deflecting and god-seeing when you pick up the pace.I think a slightly more harsh ride is excellent trade off here.
Power wise there is really no comparison.The Berg seems to chuck more rocks as he informed me of getting numerous rock showers even when following from what he thought was a "safe" distance.I found this quite amusing untill we switched bikes and I got nailed in the nose by a rock from my own bike
At one straight stretch he took off and pinned it while laid down over the tank.I motored on by fully upright and waving at my indicated top speed of the day-153km/hr(no doubt the speedo is slightly optimistic but I was by no means topped out here nor did I have it to the stop)The Berg is also very stable at these types speeds such that your actual speed seems a little deceiving.
At about the farthest point from home he had to go on reserve.He limped his way back home in a high gear at low rpm's while I rode back and forth,wheelied past him and generally made an obnoxious pain in the A of myself.It seems odd that,even through a helmet,you get the impression you're getting dirty looks
Regardless,we both made it back-him with about a cupful to spare and me with,as near as I can judge,about 1/3 of a tank remaining.
His certainly isn't rich off the bottom at least as it generates a horrendous amount of lean backfiring on the overrun.
We were discussing the obvious economy differences and I mentioned about the Lineaweaver jet kit and the disabled accellerator pump no doubt helping here.He wanted to know if you could get one for his.I said I didn't think so but I'd check.Dale?
Another interesting note;he asked what the red knob on the carb was.I told him the same as his-hot start.He said his didn't have one so I looked and sure enough,it doesn't.The port for it is blocked off.I know the older RFS KTM's had them but wasn't aware the new EXC's didn't.
After switching off he was going on and on about big power,torque etc,etc and said"I should have bought a 525" :roll: I said,or maybe a 550 After everything he said about the Berg I though I sould say something I liked about his but all I could come up with was"your's has a nice soft seat"It sounded kind of lame and generated a bit of a look but I think that was honestly all I preffered on the KTM.
In the end though I think the KTM is a great bike.If your thing is slow,sit down type trail plonking in an XR400 sort of way,the KTM would be hard to beat.For everything else,I'd take the Berg.The usual minor setup things but other than that I think this is definately the right choice.Besides,I love all the noises from the intake,exhaust and engine-mechanical music-sort of like the Ducati of dirtbikes :lol:
Anyway,here goes
Temp-60'F Elevation 200-700' asl.Ride-too much fireroad with some snotty singletrack and mud and rocks and roots.Less of the latter than intended due to the fact that I was unable to fid my way due to excessive clearcutting and new logging roads.
All in all the bike was amazing.I had heard that these could be intimidating but it didn't seem so at all.All kinds of power if you wanted it but enough torque to pull a taller gear at lower speeds if you didn't.
Jetting-close,but not quite.I can't speak for the stock jetting as this bike had the Lineaweaver jet kit installed from new.Bill,the mechanic at Valley Yamaha wasn't happy with the stock set up so that was good enough for me.I had a hard time kick starting it at these temps with my mx boots(e start worked readily enough)Also had a slight lean hesitation off the bottom and slight popping on closed throttle.However,I can kickstart it easily in the basement with my slippers on(wife takes exception to this for some reason)where the temp is about 70 degrees.For now I plan to richen up the fuel screw slightly as the weather is cool and I expect as soon as it warms up to the usual summer riding temps the jetting will be spot on.I may end up going one size larger on the pilot for spring and fall but I'll wait and see.Having the accelerator pump hooked up would have no doubt been an aid for cold starting but given how it starts at a slightly warmer temp I expect this won't be an issue with some minor adjustments.Not that I doubt Mr. Lineaweavers credentials or abilities,but having been an auto mechanic for 20+years and being well familiar with the old days of carburetors and accelerator pumps and the purpose of the pump as well as the resulting problems when they went bad(and also coming off a two stroke)I had my doubts that you could disable the pump and still be able to whack it open at low rpm to clear a rock or log without having it bog.As it turned out,it has no bog whatsoever.Even the slight lean hesitation is no issue as it blows past this point and puts you straight up in a hurry-and this is from second gear at a rockcrawling pace.I guess I should have known.Sorry Dale
Suspension-pretty good but seems to have a tendency to wash the front end out.The first time it did this I made a heroic attempt to dab with my head but this proved less than effective.After that I was prepared for it and managed to compensate.This may be my own doing as I have the rear sag set at 105mm so may have to jack this up a bit.I took a few hard hits at speed as well as a few slap down wheelies and small woods type jumps and still had about 2.5" of unused front travel(I have o rings on the lower tubes)so I may have some adjustment range here as well.
Handling-seems good but slower than what I'm used too(02 KTM 125SX)
When weighting the pegs for a left,right,left transition to go around rocks or whatever it takes a little more time to initiate.Given the engine size and weight this wasn't unexpected.I think a little fine tuning is in order but all in all it seems to work very well and tracks straight over the crappiest of terrain.
Engine- :shock: :shock: :shock: Yahooooo..all kinds everywhere.What more can you say.I now have 118km/2.7 hrs on it so I changed the oil and filter.Oil looks slightly dark with some sludge on the magnet.The screen has a dozen small chips on it and the inside of the filter has just a couple small chips in it.Nothing at all like the scary looking long slivers I used to get off previous KTM's.
Misc.-I love the adjustable brake pedal.For some reason,my toes always hang down past the front of the pegs when sitting or standing and I've never been able to position it in such a way that I don't have to ride with my foot pointed out or dragging the rear brake-until now.It seems like a small thing but it makes a big difference to me.
As for a comparison of the two,I couldn't get over how soft and cushy his seat was.My previous KTM's(an EXC and an SX)were hard as a board.The Berg seat is better than those but his seat is better than that.Soft and cushy but you don't feel the base.It reminds me of a Honda seat.Not a big issue but definately noticeable.
The other thing I noticed when getting on the EXC was how low it sat.The suspension hardly sagged with my weight(I'm 160,he's 210)I could flat foot it with a slight bend in my knees.This was good for getting your foot down to save it at times but it was also a much more scrunched up riding position.I have bar risers on the Berg but even allowing for this the EXC position seemed much more compact.The KTM is also more plush in the slow going rocky stuff but it is also more prone to goat dancing,head shaking,deflecting and god-seeing when you pick up the pace.I think a slightly more harsh ride is excellent trade off here.
Power wise there is really no comparison.The Berg seems to chuck more rocks as he informed me of getting numerous rock showers even when following from what he thought was a "safe" distance.I found this quite amusing untill we switched bikes and I got nailed in the nose by a rock from my own bike
At one straight stretch he took off and pinned it while laid down over the tank.I motored on by fully upright and waving at my indicated top speed of the day-153km/hr(no doubt the speedo is slightly optimistic but I was by no means topped out here nor did I have it to the stop)The Berg is also very stable at these types speeds such that your actual speed seems a little deceiving.
At about the farthest point from home he had to go on reserve.He limped his way back home in a high gear at low rpm's while I rode back and forth,wheelied past him and generally made an obnoxious pain in the A of myself.It seems odd that,even through a helmet,you get the impression you're getting dirty looks
Regardless,we both made it back-him with about a cupful to spare and me with,as near as I can judge,about 1/3 of a tank remaining.
His certainly isn't rich off the bottom at least as it generates a horrendous amount of lean backfiring on the overrun.
We were discussing the obvious economy differences and I mentioned about the Lineaweaver jet kit and the disabled accellerator pump no doubt helping here.He wanted to know if you could get one for his.I said I didn't think so but I'd check.Dale?
Another interesting note;he asked what the red knob on the carb was.I told him the same as his-hot start.He said his didn't have one so I looked and sure enough,it doesn't.The port for it is blocked off.I know the older RFS KTM's had them but wasn't aware the new EXC's didn't.
After switching off he was going on and on about big power,torque etc,etc and said"I should have bought a 525" :roll: I said,or maybe a 550 After everything he said about the Berg I though I sould say something I liked about his but all I could come up with was"your's has a nice soft seat"It sounded kind of lame and generated a bit of a look but I think that was honestly all I preffered on the KTM.
In the end though I think the KTM is a great bike.If your thing is slow,sit down type trail plonking in an XR400 sort of way,the KTM would be hard to beat.For everything else,I'd take the Berg.The usual minor setup things but other than that I think this is definately the right choice.Besides,I love all the noises from the intake,exhaust and engine-mechanical music-sort of like the Ducati of dirtbikes :lol: