To the suitably knowledgeable, what should I be looking for as the root cause of the failure?
Left Side Crank Bearing
2005 FE450E
90 hrs
5800 km's
SKF Bearing
[/URL][/IMG]
I have a 2004 FE 450 which chewed up it's mains like this. Initially when the bike was bought it had a broken valve spring, but I opened the cases anyway to see what's going on inside. All seemed well, except for the crank runout, so I had it trued and re-assembled, I use 0.5mm endfloat.
Engine ran about 20hrs before chewing up the drive side main. These were the OEM SKF mains. So I replaced the mains, and had to have the crank trued again, at this stage maybe alarm bells should have started ringing, but I assumed that the crank runout may have gone out due to the hammering from the worn main bearing. This time I used Rollway nj2206 on the drive side and an NTN(the Pro-X one) on ignition side.
Once again about 20hrs running, bike started sounding noisy, so I took the ignition cover off to feel the main bearing there, and I could move the magneto up and down ever so slightly.
So I pulled the engine apart again, and this time it was the ignition side main that was starting to go. Looking at the Rollway 2206 inner race on the crank, the roller 'track' mark is right in the center of the race, which I would consider to be a good thing, but the race on the ignition side, the 'track' is right up on the inside, against the lip, and I can clearly see the marks on the rollers and the lip of the inner race where they ran against each other. This is also where the inner race had started to deteriorate, right against the lip the edges of the little raduis there was starting to flake. Also, the crank runout was once again waaaay out.
So it seems to me that the interference fit between the bigend pin and the crank webs is too little and the crank starts wobbling and destroys the main bearing. I suppose welding the pin will sort this problem, or maybe heating the web and quenching in oil may cause the hole to 'shrink' a bit and get the interference right? I don't know if this heat treatment will affect the crank in a bad way?
My real question here, is wether the crank tends to push to the left, or to the right side when under load, so if everything else is correct, will the crank use the drive side or the ign side bearing as a stop? Or is it supposed to run in the center with a little bit of endfloat on each side?
I know as mentioned in another post, the use of a locating bearing on one side is meant to keep the crank locked in place on one bearing, and allow a little bit of movement on the other, which is what the Jap bikes use.